Wellness, recipes and everyday rituals for a well-loved life.

Heart Habits
Books

How to Start a Winter Book Club, Plus 8 Books Worth Discussing

A practical guide to starting or refreshing a book club this winter: group size, how often to meet, hosting, questions and 8 discussable picks.

We independently pick everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, Heart Habits may earn a commission. Learn more

Two older women sit in armchairs at a cozy indoor book club meeting, one smiling in the foreground as she listens while the other holds an open book.
Pexels / Centre for Ageing Better

Here’s the short version: a good book club needs five to eight people, one evening a month, a book most of you can actually finish and someone willing to ask the first question. Everything else, from the snacks to the wine to the perfect spreadsheet of picks, is optional.

Winter is the best time to start one, or to bring a sleepy one back to life. The evenings are long, everyone’s looking for a reason to leave the house that isn’t another errand, and January is full of fresh-start energy. Below is how to set it up so it lasts past February, plus eight books that give a group plenty to talk about.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Start with the right size

Aim for five to eight members. With fewer than five, one cancellation and it’s just two of you staring at a cheese plate. Much more than eight, and the quieter people stop talking and the evening splits into side conversations.

If you’re starting from scratch, invite two or three friends and ask each of them to bring one person you don’t know. You’ll get a mix of tastes, and new faces make people a little more likely to have done the reading.

Pick a rhythm you can keep

Once a month is the sweet spot for most groups. It’s enough time to read a 300-page novel without cramming, and it’s frequent enough that the club feels like a habit, not a special event.

Set a standing slot, like the second Tuesday of the month, so nobody has to coordinate calendars every time. Over the holidays, it’s fine to skip December or swap it for a low-key “bring a book you loved this year” night with no assigned reading at all.

How to choose the books

Rotate who picks. The host for the month chooses, or offers a shortlist of three and the group votes. Rotating keeps one person’s taste from taking over, and it means everyone gets to share a favorite.

Mind the length. For most months, stick to books under about 350 pages. Save the big ones for a stretch like the holidays, when people have more time, or split a long book across two meetings.

Check availability. Before you lock in a pick, make sure it’s in paperback or easy to borrow. Library holds on a popular new book can take weeks, so choose a month or two ahead.

Mix it up. Alternate new books with older ones, and fiction with the occasional memoir. A backlist title is usually cheaper and easier to find, and the conversation is often just as good.

Pick for talk, not just for love. The best book club books aren’t always everyone’s favorites. Look for a narrator you’re not sure you trust, a choice you’d argue about or an ending people will read differently.

Hosting without the stress

Keep the food simple. A potluck, a pot of soup or a plate of cookies and some tea is plenty, and an easy menu means anyone can host, not just the person with the biggest dining table. If your group likes a theme, a dish from the book’s setting is a fun bonus, not a requirement.

Set a start and end time, and give the first half hour to catching up. Then move into the book on purpose, or you’ll look up at 9:30 and realize nobody has mentioned it.

Make room for people who can’t come in person. A phone propped on a bookshelf with a video call open works fine in a pinch, and it keeps members in the loop through snowstorms and sick kids.

Questions that get people talking

Start with a quick round: everyone gives the book a thumbs-up, thumbs-down or a shrug, plus one sentence on why. It gets every voice into the room early, and you’ll see right away where the disagreements are.

After that, open-ended questions work better than quiz questions. A few that fit almost any book:

  • Which character would you most like to have dinner with, and which would you avoid?
  • Was there a moment where you changed your mind about someone?
  • What do you think happens after the last page?
  • If this book were a movie, what would the poster look like?
  • Would you recommend it to your mother, your best friend or your teenager? Why?

Many publishers post free reading group guides on their book pages, so check before you write your own. And make it a rule that people who didn’t finish are still welcome. Start with spoiler-light questions, then open it up, so a member who comes anyway is a member who comes back.

8 books worth discussing this winter

These are sorted by length, from slim picks you can finish over a long weekend to big novels for a slow, snowy month. Page counts are for the hardcover unless I say otherwise, and they can differ a bit between editions.

Under 300 pages

The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro (1989)

Good for: Groups who like a quiet book with a lot underneath · About 256 pages (paperback)

Stevens has been the butler at Darlington Hall for three decades. On a drive through the English countryside after World War II, he looks back on his years of service to Lord Darlington, and begins to doubt both the man he served and the life he gave up for it. It won the 1989 Booker Prize, and Ishiguro later won the Nobel Prize in Literature. The Vintage paperback runs 256 pages.

Stevens tells his own story, and he doesn’t always tell the whole truth, even to himself, which gives a group plenty to unpack. It moves slowly, though, so it suits readers who like reading between the lines more than a fast plot.

The Remains of the Day

Piranesi by Susanna Clarke (2020)

Good for: Groups who want something strange and wonderful · About 272 pages

Piranesi lives in a house of endless halls lined with statues, where an ocean is trapped inside and the tides rush up the staircases. The only other person he sees is a man he calls the Other, who visits twice a week. Then he finds evidence that someone else is there, too. Bloomsbury lists it at 272 pages, and it won the Women’s Prize for Fiction in 2021.

The first few chapters can feel disorienting, so you may want to tell your group to stick with it. Once the mystery clicks, you’ll have a lot to talk about, including what’s real and what the ending means. Try not to read too much about it before you start.

Piranesi

About 300 to 350 pages

The Correspondent by Virginia Evans (2025)

Good for: A warm, easy-to-love pick · About 304 pages

Most mornings, retired lawyer Sybil Van Antwerp sits down to write letters: to her brother, her best friend, a professor who won’t let her audit his class and authors whose books she has opinions about. Then letters from someone in her past force her to face one of the most painful times in her life. The whole novel is told in letters and emails. Crown lists it at 304 pages, and it won the 2026 Women’s Prize for Fiction.

Sybil is prickly, funny and not always easy to like, which makes her great to argue about. The story touches on grief and regret, so it’s gentle rather than light. Bonus idea for your group: everyone writes one real letter before the meeting.

The Correspondent

James by Percival Everett (2024)

Good for: Groups ready for a big conversation · About 320 pages

This is Adventures of Huckleberry Finn retold by Jim, the enslaved man who runs away when he hears he’s about to be sold and separated from his wife and daughter. Penguin Random House lists it at 320 pages, and it won the 2025 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction as well as the National Book Award.

It’s gripping and often darkly funny, and it includes the violence of slavery, which some members may find hard to read. You don’t need to have read Huck Finn first, though members who have will bring a different angle.

James

Tom Lake by Ann Patchett (2023)

Good for: Multigenerational groups and family-drama fans · About 320 pages

In the spring of 2020, Lara’s three grown daughters come home to the family cherry orchard in northern Michigan. While they pick fruit, they beg her to tell them about her long-ago romance with a famous actor from her summer at a theater company called Tom Lake. HarperCollins lists it at 320 pages, and it was a Reese’s Book Club pick.

It’s a lovely book for talking about the lives our parents had before we came along, and what we choose to tell our own kids. The pace is gentle. It briefly mentions an abortion, so give your group a heads-up. If your group is tired of pandemic stories, 2020 is only the backdrop; the book isn’t really about the pandemic.

Tom Lake

Educated by Tara Westover (2018)

Good for: A memoir month · About 352 pages

Westover grew up with survivalist parents in the mountains of Idaho and didn’t set foot in a classroom until she was 17. She went on to earn a PhD from Cambridge University. Random House lists the hardcover at 352 pages, and the same publisher page calls it a #1 New York Times bestseller.

It raises big questions about family loyalty, memory and what we owe the people who raised us. It also includes violence from one of her brothers, so give your group a heads-up.

Educated

Long winter reads

The Snow Child by Eowyn Ivey (2012)

Good for: The snowiest month of the year · About 400 pages

It’s 1920 in Alaska, and Jack and Mabel are struggling on their homestead and drifting apart. During the first snowfall, they build a child out of snow. The next morning, it’s gone, and a little girl appears in the trees. Little, Brown lists the hardcover at 400 pages, and it was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction.

Your group can debate whether the girl is real or magic, and why it matters. It’s a fairy tale grounded in a hard, sometimes violent place, with sad moments, so it isn’t pure comfort reading.

The Snow Child

The Covenant of Water by Abraham Verghese (2023)

Good for: A holiday-season epic or a two-month read · About 724 pages (768 in paperback)

In 1900, in Kerala, South India, a 12-year-old girl is sent by boat to marry a 40-year-old man she has never met. The novel follows her family across three generations, through 1977, along with a strange family affliction: in every generation, someone dies by drowning. It was an Oprah’s Book Club pick, Grove’s page lists the paperback at 768 pages, and the first Grove hardcover runs 724 pages.

It’s long, so plan to split it across two meetings, or schedule it for the holidays. Some descriptions of surgery and medical procedures are detailed, which some readers love and some skim. Grove’s book page also includes a free reading group guide.

The Covenant of Water

Your first meeting, step by step

  1. Send the invite with the date, the book and the plan: “We’ll chat for half an hour, then talk about the book.”
  2. Choose a first book everyone can get easily, ideally under 300 pages.
  3. Ask each member to bring one question or one passage they marked.
  4. Start with the thumbs-up, thumbs-down round.
  5. Before everyone leaves, pick the next host, date and book, so you don’t spend the next month on group texts.

Make it a season, not a one-off

A book club works best when reading becomes something people look forward to. If you need a spot to actually do the reading, Maren’s cozy reading corner guide shows how to set one up with what you already have, and her evening wind-down rituals are a nice companion if you’d rather trade scrolling for a chapter before bed.

Members with long commutes or holiday drives can listen instead of reading. Many of these are on audio, and my Thanksgiving road-trip audiobooks guide has more picks by drive length.