Vitamin D in the Dark Months: Who Actually Needs a Supplement
Winter sun is weak, but more vitamin D isn't always better. Here's who may need a supplement, how much, the best foods, and what to ask your doctor.
Here’s the short answer: most healthy grown-ups don’t need to rush out for a vitamin D bottle the minute the days get short. But a few groups really do benefit from extra, starting with breastfed babies. Knowing which group your family is in makes this a quick chat with your doctor, not a guess in the vitamin aisle.
Why winter changes the math
Your skin makes vitamin D from sunlight, and winter makes that harder. Harvard’s Nutrition Source notes that people in Boston can’t make enough vitamin D from the sun for 4 months out of the year, because UVB light is weaker at northern latitudes.
The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements says clouds, smog, older age and darker skin all reduce how much vitamin D your skin makes, and your skin doesn’t make vitamin D from sunlight through a window. That sunny kitchen spot is lovely for your mood, but it won’t do much for your vitamin D.
The reassuring part: according to the same NIH fact sheet, most people in the United States have adequate blood levels of vitamin D. It also notes that almost one in four people have levels that are too low or inadequate for bone and overall health. That’s why “who” matters more than “everyone.”
What vitamin D actually does
Its main job is helping your body absorb calcium, one of the main building blocks for strong bones. Your muscles, nerves and immune system need it too. Over time, too little can cause rickets in kids, with soft, weak bones, and bone pain and muscle weakness in teens and adults.
How much your family needs
The NIH’s recommended daily amounts:
- Birth to 12 months: 400 IU (10 mcg)
- Ages 1 to 70, including pregnancy and breastfeeding: 600 IU (15 mcg)
- 71 and older: 800 IU (20 mcg)
These amounts assume minimal sun exposure, so they already account for a gray winter.
Who may need a supplement
Breastfed babies. This is the clearest one. The American Academy of Pediatrics says breastfed and partially breastfed infants should get 400 IU of vitamin D a day, starting in the first few days of life. Breast milk is wonderful, but the NIH notes that breast milk alone doesn’t provide enough vitamin D.
Formula-fed babies who drink less than 32 ounces a day of vitamin D-fortified formula need the same 400 IU. Your pediatrician can tell you how long to keep going.
Older kids and teens. The AAP says teens who don’t get 600 IU a day from food should get a supplement with that amount. Kids taking certain medications or living with chronic conditions, such as cystic fibrosis, may need more, so check with your pediatrician.
Other groups the NIH flags. The NIH lists people who are more likely to have trouble getting enough vitamin D:
- Older adults, because the skin makes less vitamin D with age
- People who rarely get sun on their skin, whether they’re mostly indoors or keep covered
- People with darker skin, since more melanin means less vitamin D from sunlight
- People with conditions that limit fat absorption, such as Crohn’s disease, celiac disease or ulcerative colitis
- People with obesity or who have had gastric bypass surgery
Food first: easy winter sources
The NIH points out that very few foods naturally contain vitamin D, and fortified foods provide most of it in American diets. Here’s what the NIH’s food table shows for a few family staples:
- Salmon (sockeye), cooked, 3 ounces: 570 IU
- Mushrooms exposed to UV light, raw, ½ cup: 366 IU
- Milk (2%), fortified, 1 cup: 120 IU
- Soy, almond and oat milks, fortified, 1 cup: 100 to 144 IU
- Fortified breakfast cereal, 1 serving: 80 IU (this varies, so check the label)
- Egg, 1 large, scrambled: 44 IU
A heads-up for cheese lovers: cheese and ice cream usually aren’t fortified. The Nutrition Facts label lists vitamin D, so check the carton or cereal box. A salmon dinner, fortified cereal with milk, and weekend eggs add up nicely.
More isn’t better
If some is good, more isn’t better. The NIH says too much vitamin D can cause nausea, vomiting, muscle weakness, confusion, pain, loss of appetite, dehydration, excessive urination and thirst, and kidney stones. Extremely high levels can cause kidney failure, an irregular heartbeat and even death.
High levels almost always come from supplements. The NIH says you can’t get too much vitamin D from sunshine, because your skin limits how much it makes. These are the NIH’s daily upper limits, which include food, drinks and supplements combined:
- Birth to 6 months: 1,000 IU
- 7 to 12 months: 1,500 IU
- 1 to 3 years: 2,500 IU
- 4 to 8 years: 3,000 IU
- 9 years and older, including adults: 4,000 IU
Your doctor might prescribe more than this for a while to treat a deficiency. And as the AAP reminds parents, keep vitamin D supplements out of a child’s reach.
Vitamin D can also interact with some medicines, including the weight-loss drug orlistat, cholesterol-lowering statins, steroids such as prednisone and thiazide diuretics. If anyone in your house takes a regular medication, ask your doctor or pharmacist before adding vitamin D.
Do you need a blood test?
Probably not just to check. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force concluded in 2021 that the current evidence is insufficient to assess the balance of benefits and harms of screening for vitamin D deficiency in adults without symptoms.
The Endocrine Society also doesn’t recommend routine vitamin D testing in healthy people, according to the NIH. If you have symptoms like bone pain or muscle weakness, or a condition that affects how you absorb vitamin D, your doctor may decide a test makes sense for you.
Expert groups don’t all draw the supplement line in the same place, either. NIH’s summary of the Endocrine Society’s guideline says the society recommends routine vitamin D supplementation for children and teens 1 to 18, pregnant women, adults with prediabetes and adults 75 and older, but not for healthy adults 19 to 74. It doesn’t recommend specific doses beyond the standard daily amounts. If you’re in one of these groups, that’s a good question for your next checkup.
What about mood and colds?
Mood. Some studies link low vitamin D with a higher risk of depression. But the NIH says clinical trials show that vitamin D supplements don’t prevent or ease symptoms of depression. For seasonal affective disorder (SAD), the National Institute of Mental Health says studies of vitamin D have had mixed results, with some finding it as effective as light therapy and others finding no effect. If the dark afternoons are wearing on you, our guide to resetting sleep and mood after the clocks change has gentle ideas for getting more daylight.
If you’ve felt low for weeks or can’t enjoy the things you usually love, please talk to your doctor. That deserves real care, not just a supplement. If you or someone you love is struggling or having thoughts of suicide, call or text the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988.
Colds. The NIH’s immune-health fact sheet says some studies suggest regular vitamin D might slightly reduce the risk of respiratory infections, especially in people with low levels. Other studies haven’t found that, and vitamin D doesn’t appear to help treat an infection once you have one. If someone in the house is already sick, our guide to colds, flu and RSV covers when to keep kids home.
The bottom line
If you have a breastfed baby, vitamin D drops are a clear yes, and your pediatrician can walk you through them. For everyone else, start with food and a little time outdoors when you can. Then ask your doctor whether you fall into a higher-risk group.
Talk to your doctor or your child’s pediatrician before starting any supplement, especially for kids, during pregnancy, or if anyone takes a regular medication. Bring a list of what you already take, including multivitamins, so they can check the total. Then go enjoy a cozy breakfast together.